So I’m stuck between getting a hip pack or a mini frame bag for my mtb. I really just need to carry my phone, keys, and some tools. Looks like people really like hip packs, but I just like the feeling of riding with no bags/weight on my body. I’ve found some mini frame bags (like [this EVOC](https://www.evocusa.com/products/multi-frame-pack)), but I’m not sure it’ll fit my phone, or even my bike for that matter.
What’re y’alls thoughts? I’m expecting an overwhelming majority of hip packers, but open to all suggestions. Looking for something as light and unnoticeable as possible.
by emjaycu3
5 Comments
I have a tiny little under-seat bag that just barely fits a tube + multi tool. I also have a small triangle shaped wedge frame bag that I can stuff my wallet/phone/keys into along with a couple other things like tubeless plug kit & tire levers. I’ve never needed a hip pack for carrying things.
The problem I quickly ran into was 1 bottle of water is never enough, so I almost always wear the camelbak and just throw my phone/wallet/keys in there. But I’m with you, I’d rather have the weight on the bike and not on my back if you can avoid it.
Phone/wallet/keys go in my zip-up pockets and tools go in a small seat pack under my saddle.
I have an Evoc bag about the same size as the one you linked for keeping snacks on long road rides and it definitely doesn’t fit a phone.
If you like riding without having something bouncing around on your body, I would recommend against hip packs. My recommendation for short rides is a third option, liner bibs with pockets in the back for your phone, keys, snacks etc. (I recommend voler), then get a specialized swat bottle cage with a tool mounted to the bottom of it.
Nothing wrong with also getting a small frame bag, especially the one you posted. I don’t like the kind that sit on top of your top tube cause it can hit your knees and be annoying. Regardless, I’d get the bibs with pockets.
I’m not a fan of saddle bags for mountain bikes, as they get caked in mud and dirt, and can even hit the tire on full compression if you have a nice long dropper post.
No right or wrong answer, but I hate having extra weight on the bike frame or anything that might rattle around on the frame. And I don’t want to have to remove/replace a frame bag whenever cleaning my bike (I usually spray it down quickly after most rides). Hip pack has served me well. Doesn’t move around, and I don’t even notice it most of the time. In fact, I’ve checked a few times to make sure I put it on because it feels like nothing’s there.
I have both and they both work great for shorter rides I don’t go with the hip bag and just use the bike bag if the ride is longer I use my hip bag though I have two one does bounce a little but I barely notice it the smaller one is very solid, I typically just keep the bike bag on all the time with repair essentials and the hip would be more snacks etc