Help me decide which bike to keep

I have a blue 2022 trek fx 3 and a black 2023 trek fx 3. The 2022 has a really scrawny saddle, whereas the 2023 has a more meaty and comfortable one. The 2023 comes with shimano brakes but the 2022 comes with promax f1 brakes, which i heard arent as good. The 2022 blue one has lifetime of free tuneups though, which includes chain lubing, shifter adjustments, wheel truing, and brake adjustments. In terms of looks, I like both. The blue looks more premium to me, but the matte black looks more bad ass. Which one should I keep? I plan to sell one of them.