I think the giant photo is an older photo back when it was newer, theyre both the same price and the fuji comes with an extra rim
stgross on
The geometry on this giant frame 🤮
Mountain_Champion890 on
How much are they selling the Giant for? I have the same one. I posted here and it was taken down for not being fixed speed
KungFuneral on
It’s got to be no to both, keep searching. Whatever you’re paying for either can’t be worth it.
KungPaoKidden on
Are those the only options? I’d probably pass on both.
Proud-Scallion-3765 on
What are those bars on 1?
Nomadic_Plague on
Id rather get the fuji and fix it up. Thats a 2014 ~ track classic. Those bars are silly but you can change all that. If we are looking at frames im going fuji over giant all day
MeringueWild5294 on
Second photo is a giant Bowery, they have aluminum forks. Absolutely horrible bikes, the first is slightly better but you’re picking between two evils here. Take your time and look for something with either a decent frame you can build on or some good components. These have neither.
Get the Fuji! I love mine and bought it in pretty much the same condition. Look at how attractive it is!
paperbackpiles on
Fuji for sure imo. That slant Giant geometry (opposite of a pursuit) just never looked good to me on a fixed. Feels more like a suburban dad bike.
dr_proctor75 on
I’d go with the Fuji, but I’m biased as I’ve got a 2010 Classic. Those bars need sorted out straight away
trackfiends on
I’d rather a 100% completely unrideable cracked frame no components Fuji over anything produced by giant.
Balitan_ on
I have a Fuji track in that same exact color way and a raw finish giant Bowery at my mom’s house I use when I’m in town. Fuji is more of a beater bike and giant was used as tracklocross type build
neon-neko on
The Fuji has good looking straps and the other one doesn’t. The bars on the Fuji are very aero, but rather impractical. I’d go with the Fuji track and get some different handle bars eventually.
19 Comments
#2
giant imo
giant looks more well taken care of
I think the giant photo is an older photo back when it was newer, theyre both the same price and the fuji comes with an extra rim
The geometry on this giant frame 🤮
How much are they selling the Giant for? I have the same one. I posted here and it was taken down for not being fixed speed
It’s got to be no to both, keep searching. Whatever you’re paying for either can’t be worth it.
Are those the only options? I’d probably pass on both.
What are those bars on 1?
Id rather get the fuji and fix it up. Thats a 2014 ~ track classic. Those bars are silly but you can change all that. If we are looking at frames im going fuji over giant all day
Second photo is a giant Bowery, they have aluminum forks. Absolutely horrible bikes, the first is slightly better but you’re picking between two evils here. Take your time and look for something with either a decent frame you can build on or some good components. These have neither.
https://preview.redd.it/t2n15d7plvaf1.jpeg?width=2016&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0c7fc58da632ff835351383ac6d7af815554ea55
Get the Fuji! I love mine and bought it in pretty much the same condition. Look at how attractive it is!
Fuji for sure imo. That slant Giant geometry (opposite of a pursuit) just never looked good to me on a fixed. Feels more like a suburban dad bike.
I’d go with the Fuji, but I’m biased as I’ve got a 2010 Classic. Those bars need sorted out straight away
I’d rather a 100% completely unrideable cracked frame no components Fuji over anything produced by giant.
I have a Fuji track in that same exact color way and a raw finish giant Bowery at my mom’s house I use when I’m in town. Fuji is more of a beater bike and giant was used as tracklocross type build
The Fuji has good looking straps and the other one doesn’t. The bars on the Fuji are very aero, but rather impractical. I’d go with the Fuji track and get some different handle bars eventually.
https://preview.redd.it/wo304xi52waf1.jpeg?width=4080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=753c0a0339ce93529c6acd6fecdffdb7a82e7279
Love my fuji
Both