This summer while my wife is out of the country, I finally want to have a a modern (ish) full suspension trail bike.

Thru axles front and rear, tapered head tube. No half measures.

My two candidates are as follows.

A 2022 Marin Rift Zone 2 27.5.

This is new frame set only.

It as been on the market an about a year. Size XL. Might be a little large for me but I understand these ran a little small.

They are asking $300. I’m thinking about offering $200 maybe settle on $250.

The other is a 2018 Giant Trance 3. Large. A complete bike.

For $600. It has been listed for over a year. Was thinking of offering $450.

For either bike, I have XT hydraulic brakes as well as a Deore 5100/XT 1 x 11 drivetrain hack.

For the Marin frame, I would need a 27.5 taper fork as well as a through axle boost wheel set.

Which would you choose and why?

by Returning2Riding

Share.

6 Comments

  1. If you want a custom frame up build go with the Marin. If you’re looking for ready to ride get the Giant. I tend to lean towards newer geometry and parts when it comes to buying used.

  2. uncleandata147 on

    Have a Trance and love it, they are impossible to kill, no experience with a Marin though.

    I will say I spent a season on an incorrectly sized bike and didn’t realise how much it sucked until I changed to a better fit, do not discount the impact the difference in sizing may have.

  3. Your wife is out of the country… just get a new Trance, how much trouble could you get in to šŸ˜‰

Leave A Reply