I’m looking to possibly shift the saddle back 9mm, but the seatpost clamp (which is already narrow) covers the full range of allowable motion on this Selle Italia Sport Gel Flow saddle. I’m not sure if I can move into the >> area, but that would only be about 3-4mm.
The seatpost clamp is also already on a setback of about 20mm, and I’m not sure how much more you could move back on that, maybe 5mm if I got a 25mm setback seatpost
Considering just getting a new saddle outright with more play on the saddle rails
crack_that927 on
9mm would be about 3/8″ I’d say yeah you should be ok.
Careful-One5190 on
Those are pretty short rails without much room for fore/aft adjustment. You can exceed the recommended limits, but you’d be risking breaking the rails. I’d trust the manufacturer more so than random Redditors saying “it should be OK.” Some saddles have more adjustment. Longer setback seatposts aren’t always easy to find.
KitchenPalentologist on
I’ve exceeded the printed range of saddle rails without issues before. That doesn’t necessarily mean that you’ll also get away with it, but the risk isn’t high.
BigBadBeastMan on
“The code is more what you’d call ‘guidelines’ than actual rules.”
But use common sense: if you’re heavy, stick to the guidelines
bikerider55 on
I’ve never not been outside of the stop markers on a Selle Italia saddle.
opavuj on
Ignore the stop sign, you’ll be fine.
But if you’re pushing a saddle that far back on a setback post, you’ve likely got other fit issues to deal with.
BarkleEngine on
It’s not like the maker of the post knows which saddle will be used. Just keep it on the flat section.
Gullible_Raspberry78 on
If those are carbon, don’t. If aluminum, you can do it, but if you’re over 180lbs it might be risky.
10 Comments
I’m looking to possibly shift the saddle back 9mm, but the seatpost clamp (which is already narrow) covers the full range of allowable motion on this Selle Italia Sport Gel Flow saddle. I’m not sure if I can move into the >> area, but that would only be about 3-4mm.
The seatpost clamp is also already on a setback of about 20mm, and I’m not sure how much more you could move back on that, maybe 5mm if I got a 25mm setback seatpost
Considering just getting a new saddle outright with more play on the saddle rails
9mm would be about 3/8″ I’d say yeah you should be ok.
Those are pretty short rails without much room for fore/aft adjustment. You can exceed the recommended limits, but you’d be risking breaking the rails. I’d trust the manufacturer more so than random Redditors saying “it should be OK.” Some saddles have more adjustment. Longer setback seatposts aren’t always easy to find.
I’ve exceeded the printed range of saddle rails without issues before. That doesn’t necessarily mean that you’ll also get away with it, but the risk isn’t high.
“The code is more what you’d call ‘guidelines’ than actual rules.”
But use common sense: if you’re heavy, stick to the guidelines
I’ve never not been outside of the stop markers on a Selle Italia saddle.
Ignore the stop sign, you’ll be fine.
But if you’re pushing a saddle that far back on a setback post, you’ve likely got other fit issues to deal with.
It’s not like the maker of the post knows which saddle will be used. Just keep it on the flat section.
If those are carbon, don’t. If aluminum, you can do it, but if you’re over 180lbs it might be risky.
https://preview.redd.it/4r527mvterud1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a83f56e8e5da048c1da81588fce46e28177b65b5
Isn’t this the point of reference though where I have marked in yellow. Which would indicate you have lots of freedom to move it forward or back.
I’m no bike pro mechanic though so be nice. Lol just looking for more clarification.