How the hell does a derailleur cable do this? How frequently are you shifting? Lmao I’m picturing you shifting so fast and frequently that the shifts never complete
Train_2-Live on
Need to see more pics
yzscrum on
That is actually kind of crazy, how old is this bike?
Tomac_123 on
Could it be from movement of the suspension? Every time the rear moves, the cable housing rubbed a bit?
Similar issue a few years back on a road bike carbon frame seatstay from a mudguard essentially trying to hack through it. Wore a deep groove into the stay.
After seeking advice with detailed pics, ended up using EF1 2-part epoxy repair filler.
Still going strong now.
BUT that’s my situation and this may need a carbon filler reinforcement added as well as I see it’s broke through in one area. I’d imagine the thickness of the remainder of the groove is <1mm.
I’d say it’s repairable but to echo the comments of others, would preferably like to see more pictures
Terruhcutta on
Is your frame made of clay? Holy cow!
Big-Don-Kedic on
Honestly, I’d fill it with epoxy and send it. You can probably have someone do an actual composite repair with a patch so it holds it together better, but I wouldn’t worry too much at this location.
So my Commencal FS bike did this. It didn’t make it quite all the way through, but it was similarly deep. I had probably been riding it for a year or less when I noticed it.
I covered it with a piece of tape and it never came back. Wild how a piece of gorilla tape is somehow more resilient than a chunk of metal, but apparently it’s a thing.
I put a 180 fork on it and it has survived multiple seasons as my downhill bike.
YMMV but I think it’s a good indicator that this is not as bad as it looks. There’s no crack, no dent, no material has been bent/pushed/pulled. It is across the BB, so it’s weakening it perpendicular to the direction of travel…I just don’t think it’s going to break. The stresses on that short, stout piece of tube in that direction cannot be that high.
I say send it.
Right after you file the sharp bits and tape it, anyway…
ronniearnold on
Just curious, do you WANT to ride on this? A broken back would be WAY worse than getting this replaced/fixed.
Good luck…
badger906 on
I’ve seen this a few times in my frame painting days. Realistically the frames fine. It’s not going to fail. i tend to fibre glass body fill it, sand and paint. Good as new
I don’t know why people are buying carbon fiber frames AL is the way to go only time is if you were a professional racer and the bike was given to you for free
18 Comments
How the hell does a derailleur cable do this? How frequently are you shifting? Lmao I’m picturing you shifting so fast and frequently that the shifts never complete
Need to see more pics
That is actually kind of crazy, how old is this bike?
Could it be from movement of the suspension? Every time the rear moves, the cable housing rubbed a bit?
https://www.easycomposites.co.uk/black-epoxy-repair-filler
Similar issue a few years back on a road bike carbon frame seatstay from a mudguard essentially trying to hack through it. Wore a deep groove into the stay.
After seeking advice with detailed pics, ended up using EF1 2-part epoxy repair filler.
Still going strong now.
BUT that’s my situation and this may need a carbon filler reinforcement added as well as I see it’s broke through in one area. I’d imagine the thickness of the remainder of the groove is <1mm.
I’d say it’s repairable but to echo the comments of others, would preferably like to see more pictures
Is your frame made of clay? Holy cow!
Honestly, I’d fill it with epoxy and send it. You can probably have someone do an actual composite repair with a patch so it holds it together better, but I wouldn’t worry too much at this location.
How the…
Lol at that little strip of protective 3M tape.
https://preview.redd.it/slg0rnjsrdzg1.jpeg?width=1800&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5071effe64f9caac09bcc13e1e337c0933287e54
another pic
https://preview.redd.it/ueto6sjurdzg1.jpeg?width=1800&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6e32479ebf6f63ac63279ddfa0a866160455c8b3
pic 3
https://preview.redd.it/u1e6z30wrdzg1.jpeg?width=1800&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=49312f17ca1ab8ec65cfa7728db83b6569e828c7
pic 4
So my Commencal FS bike did this. It didn’t make it quite all the way through, but it was similarly deep. I had probably been riding it for a year or less when I noticed it.
I covered it with a piece of tape and it never came back. Wild how a piece of gorilla tape is somehow more resilient than a chunk of metal, but apparently it’s a thing.
I put a 180 fork on it and it has survived multiple seasons as my downhill bike.
YMMV but I think it’s a good indicator that this is not as bad as it looks. There’s no crack, no dent, no material has been bent/pushed/pulled. It is across the BB, so it’s weakening it perpendicular to the direction of travel…I just don’t think it’s going to break. The stresses on that short, stout piece of tube in that direction cannot be that high.
I say send it.
Right after you file the sharp bits and tape it, anyway…
Just curious, do you WANT to ride on this? A broken back would be WAY worse than getting this replaced/fixed.
Good luck…
I’ve seen this a few times in my frame painting days. Realistically the frames fine. It’s not going to fail. i tend to fibre glass body fill it, sand and paint. Good as new
dude’s derailleur cables are a menace ðŸ˜[](https://emojipedia.org/loudly-crying-face)
Plastic frame plastic problems. Ride steel.
I don’t know why people are buying carbon fiber frames AL is the way to go only time is if you were a professional racer and the bike was given to you for free