Do any tall people ride a frame that is smaller than they measure up for?
I am looking for a new commute bike after my beloved Specialized Alibi was stolen. It was a faithful companion for 10 years and many thousands of kms… the only problem was that I always felt the XL frame was too big. I am 6’5 and I measure up for an XL frame, but when I test ride bikes now I feel more at home on a Large frame. The Specialized was a great bike, however I had to put an adjustable stem on it to bring the bars closer to me to ride more upright.
Does anyone else ride a bike that is “technically” too small for them on paper? Are there any potential issues that I could run into if I get a smaller frame bike?
Thanks 😊✌️
by benjo83
7 Comments
It’s super common, for a variety of reasons. The one you have is one I’ve heard before for sure.
If you’re comfortable I think the only real issue that can arise is if you have the seatpost too high to accommodate your height. Seatposts will usually have a line to indicate what’s “too high”
I ride a 53cm frame but my height requires a 54. I played with the seat height and the ride is fine now. But your case is drastically different.
I’m average height, and prefer a large frame because I have long limbs/short torso.
It all depends on how your body is proportioned.
Everyone’s body geo is different and frame size recommendations are based on averages and benchmarks and what not. If you feel more comfortable on a smaller frame, so long as you don’t exceed the frame’s limitations (like seat post height) then you should be good to go. Ideally try and see prospective bikes in person so you can try the two sizes to see which one feels best.
I’m 6’1 and some bike dudes have mentioned that I look a little big for my Large frame bike. It feels just right for me though so I’m all good with it. Do you.
If you use a bike that’s too small, it’ll be harder on your knees. And I don’t think you need me to tell you to take care of your knees
I’ll also point out that frame geometry has changed significantly over time, and lots of people size down from what they got 10+ years ago.