I had this issue for months by using a low quality Amazon tool and assumed that’s just how annoying BBs are. I then tried a park tools one and I can’t express how much easier it was
damplamb on
I would guess that something is in the spline on the bb. Not uncommon for small stones to get lodged in there. Use a straight pick to clean everything out and try again.
psyentologists on
I think it’s a combination of a low quality tool and an inability to get purchase.
The first thing anyone removing a bottom bracket like this should do it dispense with Allen keys, sockets, or whatever else they have that fits on the end of the tool, and [get one of these](https://www.amazon.com/Pedros-Socket-Holder-Tool-Splined/dp/B07CRMRJ48) (or make their own). Use the socket holder to affix the splined tool firmly in place and use a large adjustable wrench to tighten or loosen the BB.
goodenuffiguess on
Find a long bolt that will thread into the bb end. Pass that bolt (probably in conjunction w a washer) through your tool and securely attach it to the bb. This will keep the tool from shifting and likely cause all the splines to engage fully. Then use a large adjustable wrench (and a cheater bar if necessary) to break the bb loose. Non- drive side first. This is how I loosen stubborn sq taper bb’s. Your tool may be just fine once it is attached to the bb more securely.
Diogenes256 on
I don’t know if this would work on a BB, but… I have used a skewer to hold the cassette tool on a rear wheel to loosen the lock ring. Might help if it works.
turbo451 on
At the very last second of the video it appears there may be a spacer on the spindle that the tool is contacting, preventing full engagement.
driplord207 on
Buy a park tools tool. Those amazon tools are junk. I learned my lesson and never buy anything from Amazon anymore unless its PT.
Own-Flatworm-971 on
I have used a large C clamp to hold the tool and ratchet in place. This prevents the tool from slipping out.
Exciting-Carob9393 on
I’ve managed to secure the tool in place now just need to find an adjustable wrench 🔧 thanks all and props to @goodenuffiguess for the tip
12 Comments
is that a crank puller?
I had this issue for months by using a low quality Amazon tool and assumed that’s just how annoying BBs are. I then tried a park tools one and I can’t express how much easier it was
I would guess that something is in the spline on the bb. Not uncommon for small stones to get lodged in there. Use a straight pick to clean everything out and try again.
I think it’s a combination of a low quality tool and an inability to get purchase.
The first thing anyone removing a bottom bracket like this should do it dispense with Allen keys, sockets, or whatever else they have that fits on the end of the tool, and [get one of these](https://www.amazon.com/Pedros-Socket-Holder-Tool-Splined/dp/B07CRMRJ48) (or make their own). Use the socket holder to affix the splined tool firmly in place and use a large adjustable wrench to tighten or loosen the BB.
Find a long bolt that will thread into the bb end. Pass that bolt (probably in conjunction w a washer) through your tool and securely attach it to the bb. This will keep the tool from shifting and likely cause all the splines to engage fully. Then use a large adjustable wrench (and a cheater bar if necessary) to break the bb loose. Non- drive side first. This is how I loosen stubborn sq taper bb’s. Your tool may be just fine once it is attached to the bb more securely.
I don’t know if this would work on a BB, but… I have used a skewer to hold the cassette tool on a rear wheel to loosen the lock ring. Might help if it works.
At the very last second of the video it appears there may be a spacer on the spindle that the tool is contacting, preventing full engagement.
Buy a park tools tool. Those amazon tools are junk. I learned my lesson and never buy anything from Amazon anymore unless its PT.
I have used a large C clamp to hold the tool and ratchet in place. This prevents the tool from slipping out.
I’ve managed to secure the tool in place now just need to find an adjustable wrench 🔧 thanks all and props to @goodenuffiguess for the tip
https://preview.redd.it/fd2wocrtgm5g1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=40468275d9db7b360ba027f7d2139cbe11c1745d
Wrong tool. Find a long bolt or get a [proper one](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/GooAAOSw8rFlWhFv/s-l1200.jpg) which is going to hold the piece while you twist.
BB is damaged.