Is this Giant Avail good option for $200?

I’m in between this and a trek 2011-2016 (ish) alpha series (posted this yesterday). Would be my first ever roadbike! Will use for commuting sometimes and exercise/recreational. (Will also post the trek pics for comparison! The trek is being offered for $ 250)

GIANT: 200$
Aluminum
Size M
Aluminum wheels set 700×23
Shimano components

TREK: 250$

Specs:
Frame: Trek Alpha 1.5 Aluminum frame, Carbon fork, 27-speed, 54cm
Shifters: Shimano Tiagra STI 3×9
Derailleurs: Shimano Tiagra
Brakes: Shimano dual pivot
Crankset: FSA triple crankset
Rims: Bontrager Rims 700c
Tires: Continental Ultra Sport 700x23c
Saddle: Specialized

by Vinny_0808_0707