Why are people leaving Paris? Thanks to Linjer for sponsoring this video! Click here https://linjer.co/shop-with-Lucile and use my code LUCILE
Paris is losing people every year. I’m French, I live in Paris and today I want to give you my honest thoughts on why people are leaving Paris. Paris has lost 718,946 inhabitants since its peak in 1921 and has been steadily losing people since 2007 (source INSEE). Every year there are very extreme articles and headlines about this topic and we’re unpacking them today to see if they are true or not!
– Get $5 off my PARIS FOOD MAP with over 200 delicious spots I’ve personally been to and recommend: https://www.paris.lucilehr.com/products/paris-food-map?promo=YT
—
Watch my other cultural commentary videos:
– Why is it so Easy to be Thin in France? https://youtu.be/sHKXlAnVgo8?si=KOZxQ3ClzcytMq1E
– Why Are French People So Rude? My Thoughts as Local! https://youtu.be/GkxzKuL5gP4?si=p5fXjIv9oCrx8wrz
– Why Parisians are Forced to Live in Tiny Apartments: https://youtu.be/oWwyZUe6MjY?si=udcnnZf59I569gi2
– Why France Has Better Food Than The USA: https://youtu.be/C7fIHeVypdI?si=18f2MiAC8TEeLNrk
—
Tags:
#paris #france #lifeinparis #byalocal #travel #parisfrance #linjer #jewelry
Look at this graph of how many people live in
Paris. It kind of seems like everyone is leaving. And if you believe the news, it is proof the city
is dying. But I’m French, and I live in Paris, and let me tell you—I don’t think this is the
full story. So let’s investigate together and find out why everyone is leaving Paris.
So did you know that 93% of Parisians, me included, love living in Paris? That was
really surprising to me because we always hear that Paris is polluted, stressful, expensive,
all concrete. Seriously, I thought I was part of a minority of people who think Paris
is an amazing place to live. But actually, it turns out that most people living here love it.
Obviously, like in every big city, there are still a lot of problems. But there are so many
great things to do here that make life so fun—like delicious restaurants, cool museums
and culture. And of course, just walking around is an adventure, since the city is so beautiful.
But you know, as I always say on the channel, just enjoying a place as a visitor doesn’t really mean
you’re going to love living there. And this is why the city of Paris has done a lot of work to make
the city better for the people who live there. The biggest example of that is pollution
levels—they have dropped so much. Seriously, look at this evolution over the years. Or
even this before-and-after picture of the Eiffel Tower. It’s pretty impressive. And it
has made a big difference for me personally because I love biking and walking around.
And this is another thing that is much better now. When I moved to Paris around 10 years ago, it
really felt like the city was made for cars. But now it feels like the city is made for the people
to enjoy. Like there are so many more bike lanes, more sidewalks and walking streets, and so
many more parks—which is where everyone goes to hang out. Like seriously, as soon as it’s
sunny, you can find us all picnicking outside. These are just a few things that have gotten
better in Paris. And I’m not the only one who thinks this way. Like now, Paris even ranks
pretty high on a lot of those “best cities in the world” lists, which really goes against the
stereotype of this city being an unlivable place that so many people still believe in today.
But all right—if Paris is so amazing, why do around two-thirds of people, including
me as well, say they want to leave someday? And the truth is, people don’t really leave
Paris because they don’t like it. People leave because they can’t afford it anymore.
So to put things in context, let me give you an example. To be able to afford a 40 m²
apartment—so that’s like a big studio or a tiny one-bedroom—you now need to earn €97K a year
before taxes. Just to make it clear, this is not realistic. €97K is a really high salary for Paris.
The median salary in the Paris region is around €41K a year. So there’s quite a big gap.
And to put it simply, it’s like needing a Wall Street salary to live in a dorm room.
Also, if you’re renting, things are pretty expensive as well. The average rent price of
a studio apartment in Paris is €800. And I’ve already made a full video on small studios
and why there are so many of them in Paris. But one thing that’s really crazy to me is
that while people are struggling to find a place to live, there are so many apartments
that just sit empty in Paris. In Paris, one in five apartments stays empty most of the
year—and even more in richer neighborhoods that have a lot of vacation homes like the 6th, the
7th, or the 8th. There, between 30 and 36% of apartments have no one living in them year-round.
And I’ve talked about the fancy vacation homes in Paris’ most luxurious neighborhoods of the
6th in this video already. But actually, most of the places that are not used as long-term
homes are just short-term rentals, like Airbnbs. Over the past 10 years, there’s been a
short-term rental boom in Paris. Like, a lot of investors bought tiny apartments to put
them on platforms like Airbnb or VRBO, because those are more profitable than renting long-term.
The problem is—those tiny apartments? They’re exactly what students and young professionals
are looking for. So now there’s just not enough of them. I found that around 10% of
apartments are now short-term rentals in Paris. And just to give you an idea of how crazy it is to
find an apartment in Paris—for each apartment ad, there’s an average of 44 people applying.
But that’s not even the full story, because the good apartments? They
can have hundreds of people applying. Like, when we were looking for a place around
a year and a half ago, all the landlords kept telling me that they felt so overwhelmed with
the amount of phone calls they were receiving, and they just couldn’t keep up.
Also, good luck if you’re thinking of buying as well. Like, I’ve recently been
looking into buying a two-bedroom—nothing fancy, just a nice place to settle down a bit more—and
it has been crazy. So as you can expect, everything is extremely expensive. But also,
everything is so bad. Like, since Paris is a very old city, most of these apartments
have not been renovated to modern standards. For example, we visited a cute place, and the
electricity had not been changed in 20 years, and there was a risk of getting electrocuted.
Like, if I’m getting electrocuted, I want that to be free—I don’t want to spend 600 grand on it.
So I don’t know. Maybe this is me being too picky. Like seriously, if you’re a good realtor
in Paris, please write to me, because right now I’m so desperate and I feel like my only
option if I want to settle down is to move out. And before we move forward, I wanted to
tell you about today’s sponsor—Linjer. to settle down are moving out of Paris—especially
people who want to have kids. Like, look at this graph of babies being born in Paris over the
past 10 years. It’s very telling. There’s a downward trend. And overall, there are way fewer
families with kids in Paris than in the rest of the Paris region, which is mostly where
the people who are leaving Paris are going. So around two-thirds of people who leave Paris
go to the Paris region. And it is insane how big the Paris region has gotten over the past
few years. Like in this graph—the bottom line is the Paris population over time,
and the blue one is the Greater Paris area. Look at this growth. It is crazy.
And since I’m in my 30s, I’ve had quite a few friends move to the suburbs over the past
few years. And it is true that it’s cheaper, and you can get a bigger apartment for your
budget. But on my side, I’ve had even more friends move back to Toulouse, which is where I’m
from and where I am right now filming this video. And to be honest, being here feels like every
Parisian dream. Like, look at my background. And people who move back to their hometown often
want a bigger house, maybe with a garden, often a chiller life, and being closer to family.
Also, I don’t know about other cities, but Toulouse is a city that’s extremely
close to my heart. Like, I often bond with other people about being from Toulouse,
and I really feel attached to this city. But you know, the reality is that it’s
still a big city. Like, if I moved here, it would not only be chilling on the terrace—but
maybe spending hours in traffic. And, you know, maybe, let’s say, I would not be
living in the city center either. And here, I’m again not alone in my dilemma of
moving or staying in Paris, since just like me, around two-thirds of Parisians were not born in
Paris. Like, a lot of people just go to Paris for college, maybe a first job, and then move back
to their hometown when it’s time to settle down. And according to urban planner Martin Omhovère,
that’s kind of normal. In a Le Monde article, he says Paris is basically designed for
young people or couples starting out, who usually leave once they have kids. And
he also says that it’s not just a Paris thing—it also happens in other cities.
And I totally agree with him. And in my experience, this has been very true. I’ve seen my
friends from Toulouse move out to the suburbs. And being in an international relationship with an
American, we’ve also seen our friends from New York or Chicago move out to the burbs as well.
Also, every few years, we have news articles talking about how everyone is leaving Paris like
it’s breaking news. But if you look at the cool graph I showed you before, you’ll see that this
is not new, and Paris has slowly been losing people since the early 20th century.
Like, Paris is very small in size, and people have been looking for
better places to live since forever. But what is kind of new though, and not normal
at all in my opinion, is why people are leaving now. The same thing is happening in more and more
cities around the world—big and small. So it’s not that people are like, “We would like to live in a
house and maybe have a backyard.” It’s more like, “We’re working full-time, but we can’t
afford to live here unless we’re rich or we have inherited an apartment.”
And that’s actually one of the reasons why I’ve always kind of felt like a guest
in my own city. Like, I love living here, I want to keep living here, but I sometimes wonder
how much of a future I have here if the people around me can’t afford to stay here long-term.
And that’s all from me today! If you enjoyed this video, watch one of these that are
on screen right now. I’ll see you there.
27 Comments
That first chart? Was that central Paris? I expected to see figures closer to around 10m to 12m? Not 2m as a population…
You are ignoring one factor, immigration.
Can you address if there is an aging population in Paris? Can a retiree (a bit more financially established) live there?
I’m retired at 47, went from Grace to Grace. This video here reminds me of my transformation from a nobody to good home, honest partner and $65,000 biweekly and a good daughter full of love ❤️
Paris needs to allow the construction of more and bigger apartment buildings! Let supply meet demand so that Paris can be for everybody 🙂
way to expensive. I was in teh area as a young engineer. had to leave more than an hour away from my work. end up quiting after 11 month. first jobless but happy and the for a job somewhere else. I get ocntacted every now and then for jobs in teh area, my criteria is clear, either they pay enough to have a location nearby or I don´t even look at it. usually they drop my case quickly.
Not really a population decline. The authorities are artificially keeping the size of paris small when by now it should have absorbed 10 times its size in its suburbds (like london did in the 50ies). Paris is the size of Manhattan. So people are moving from paris to the closeby suburbs just 5 to 10 miles away.
Dang, this is kinda sad. I kinda want to raise children in a city.
My family left in the 1800s they come to America
American here. I wish that I could download the French language into my family’s brains so that I could apply for jobs in France & get out of this awful country… but yeah, common big city problem.
VOTE Liberal, vote liberal, vote liberal vote liberal vote liberal stop complaining vote liberal you got what you want, you all not allowed to live thats a discrimination xenophobia rascim town racism vote liberal everybody there town phobiantist vote liberal
i can't find the video but some creator recently did an amazing video on mexico city expats, with rent caps and freezes helping keep the city affordable while welcoming newcomers and keeping residents at ease. maybe paris could adopt similarly
Most of the Europe is dying because they have let in people that share the same culture that has been their for centuries.
Same situation here in Prague. My friends wanted to start a family in their early 30's, both born and raised in Prague. They couldn't afford to rent or buy a bigger place here so they moved out of Prague and got a small house. For the price of a one bedroom/studio in Prague they got a small house now. The downside being the 2 hour commute to and from work.
This is why Barcelona banned Airbnb
Paris is so cooked, in Japan there’s a psychological condition called “Paris Syndrome”
Japanese people think it’s still the fancy aristocratic paradise, when they visit they get so shocked it gives them PTSD symptoms. These last for about a year when they go back to Japan. 💀😭😂
Taxation on housing is DOUBLE TAXATION and is a huge problem and should be abolished
Also people who are using housing as an investment are making a bubble that leads to reduced fertility and de-population
Most people who love Paris don’t know what life is like outside of France.
What a deceitful title. Everyone is leaving Paris ? The graph you showed in you introduction says that in 10 years, Paris has lost 7.7% of its population, and that more than 2 million people still leave there. Far from a desert, isn't it ?
I hate it.
Paris is a really great city. The population decline won’t be visible to people living there. Especially young people. However although not as bad as some countries, it is in steep population decline.
I think saw you walking a couple of days ago! ❤ I was on the phone but should have said hi. Great video
800 euros is actually cheap compared to top cities in Canada
I have been watching ur vids since month and its sad when native people are leaving this dreamy city😢.
Lyon seems to be a better option really. it is like 2 hours ffrom Marseille and Prais but still not too small and still alot of things to do.
Vast income inequality combined with Airbnb has literally destroyed many cities here in the US. Locals are priced out, local culture is lost, gentrification occurs, and working class homes are bought up by the wealthy and investment groups for short term vacation rentals, or long term rentals after doubling the rent. It is a large factor in fueling political instability in my opinion. I'm not surprised to hear it is happening in France as well.
"C'est la vie"