Hey everyone, I’m trying to decide between two bikes, and I could use some help. Both are priced the same
1. Trek Émonda ALR 5 (2023)
• Lightweight aluminum frame with internal handlebar cable routing (which I really like!).
• Shimano 105 groupset with upgraded Dura-Ace rotors.
• FSA K-Force carbon handlebars and Bontrager RSL seatpost.
• Perfect condition with paint protection film (PPF).
• I’d have to drive about an hour to pick this one up.
2. Van Dessel Motivus Maximus (2023 Build)
• Full carbon frame, well-maintained but has 5,700 miles (half on a trainer).
• Shimano Ultegra mechanical groupset with hydraulic brakes.
• HED Ardennes alloy wheels with tubeless-ready Vittoria Rubino Pro tires.
• Zipp SL80 handlebars and Deda Zero 100 seatpost.
• Only 10 minutes away from me.
Here’s my dilemma: I’m leaning towards the Trek Émonda because I really love the clean look of the internal cable routing on the handlebars. But I’m not sure if that’s a dumb reason to decide on a bike. Both bikes have solid components, but the Van Dessel is closer and has a full carbon frame, which seems like a big plus.
Is the internal cable routing a legitimate deciding factor, or am I overthinking this? Should I prioritize the carbon frame on the Van Dessel instead? Any advice would be appreciated!
by Unhappy_Sundae_3656